Prizewinning Performance

The annual black tie back-slapping event of the year for Scotland’s political and media class is over. Kezia Dugdale was awarded the Debater of the Year award for a speech which tore apart the hypocrisy and ethics of Ruth Davidson for her support of the rape clause. Ruth Davidson was then awarded the Scottish Politician of the Year. You couldn’t really make it up.

Colonel Davidson was given the prize the day after a landmark study accused her government of “economic murder” for austerity policies which a new study suggests have caused 120,000 deaths.

The study, published in BMJ Open, focusing on England and Wales found that there were 45,000 more deaths in the first four years of Tory-led austerity than would have been expected if funding had stayed at pre-election levels.

On this trajectory that could rise to nearly 200,000 excess deaths by the end of 2020.

The study estimated that to return death rates to their pre-2010 levels spending would need to increase by £25.3bn.

In social care the annual budget increase collapsed from 2.20 per cent annually, to a decrease of 1.57 per cent.

The researchers found this coincided with death rates which had decreased by around 0.77 per cent a year to 2010, beginning to increase again by 0.87 per cent a year.

And the majority of those were people reliant on social care, the paper says: “This is most likely because social care experienced greater relative spending constraints than healthcare.”

Real terms funding for health and social care fell under the Conservative-led Coalition Government in 2010, and the study concluded this “may have produced” the substantial increase in deaths.

The Department of Health said “firm conclusions” cannot be drawn from this work, and independent academics warned the funding figures were “speculative”.

One of the study’s authors, Professor Lawrence King of the Applied Health Research Unit at Cambridge University, said it showed the damage caused by austerity.

“It is now very clear that austerity does not promote growth or reduce deficits – it is bad economics, but good class politics,” he said. “This study shows it is also a public health disaster. It is not an exaggeration to call it economic murder.”

The Herald reports from Prestonfield House Hotel that in her acceptance speech the Colonel “brought the house down with a series of quips.”

She said:

“I’m very grateful for this award tonight. I’m incredibly proud of the team that I’ve been building in Holyrood and I’m now building in Westminster – this award is very much for them.”

The award highlights the extraordinary emptiness of modern politics, in which a woman can sustain a career on slogans and photo-opportunities surrounded by a placid press corps and managing to continue with complete impunity apparently impervious to connection or culpability with her party’s government and its policies.

This feels like a value-free zone where gongs are handed out for practitioners who know how to play the game.



Comments (4)

Leave a Reply to Bella Caledonia Editor Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published.

  1. Richard MacKinnon says:

    I know you dont agree with Ruth Davidson, we all get that, but are you so blinkered that you cant see she is good at what she does? Every one else can. Not only is she an effective politician but she does it with a smile.
    The begrudging bitter tone of this article will no doubt put a big smile on her face. Keep it up. Keep your hands over the ears. Read only what you want to read. Print only those comments you want others to read.

  2. David Allan says:

    The two main award recipients reflect the banal and predicable nature of Scottish Politics . And it’s dull and boring coverage by Scotland’s MSM.

    Thankfully two former Scottish Politicians who do deserve recognition are contributing in a more positive and stimulating manner and managing to make their mark elsewhere.

    Nicola made a wrong call on this one.

    Am I alone in saying I see a trend developing.

    1. Certainly agree with the first two sentences

  3. jeouf says:

    “the study, published in BMJ Open, focusing on England and Wales…”
    We really have been written out, haven’t we?

Help keep our journalism independent

We don’t take any advertising, we don’t hide behind a pay wall and we don’t keep harassing you for crowd-funding. We’re entirely dependent on our readers to support us.

Subscribe to regular bella in your inbox

Don’t miss a single article. Enter your email address on our subscribe page by clicking the button below. It is completely free and you can easily unsubscribe at any time.