2007 - 2022



In September, in Caithness, three things happened that highlight the political dilemma Scotland is in.

First, the deployment by MayGen of four tidal stream turbines on the seabed in the Pentland Firth generated 700 Megawatt hours in August which was hailed by engineers as a tidal stream “world record”. The day after this positive announcement WWF, the conservation charity, published analysis which showed that on the day of the 19th of August alone wind turbines generated enough electricity to power nearly five million homes, or 150 per cent of Scotland’s total electricity demand. That same day in September the press reported that the proposed Moray Firth offshore wind farm will be built for £57.50 per megawatt hour, about half the price of building a wind farm two years ago. The cost for the new nuclear power station at Hinkley Point, on England’s southern coast, is £92.50 per megawatt hour.

Secondly, a consignment of weapons grade uranium, filched by the US military from sites in the former Soviet republic, and now the independent country, of Georgia in 1998 and stored at Dounreay, was flown from Wick airport in Caithness to the US nuclear complex in Savannah River in South Carolina. This bomb making material was loaded onto a giant US Airforce C-17 Globemaster transport jet, which had to off-load fuel at RAF Lossiemouth because the runway at Wick is 1,1712 feet too short for a fully fuelled Globemaster to get airborne. The C-17 then refuels at Lossiemouth and subsequently crosses the Atlantic to Tennessee. All this as the UK governments terror level was raised to “critical” as two days previous there had been a serious tube bomb attack in London. This is the third such flight and there are up to ten more such risky adventures expected in the future as the decommissioning of Dounreay continues.

Thirdly, some days later, the UK Government’s Department for Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy snubbed an application by Atlantis Resources, the parent company of MayGen, to provide support for the expansion of the Pentland Firth tidal power scheme, casting doubt over the future of this revolutionary energy project. The plan was to install a total of 49 turbines on the seabed (the final ambitious total is for 269 turbines, producing enough power for 175,000 homes) which, according to Atlantis would create 5,300 jobs, which would go some way to compensate for the eventual loss of the 2,000 jobs at Dounreay, the downturn in the North Sea oil and gas sector which has a big impact in the Far North, and would put Scotland at the forefront of a major global industry for decades.

These, to my mind at least, highlight Scotland’s weak political position within the current British constitutional set up, because our democratically elected Parliament in Holyrood with its SNP Government can do nothing about any of this. Energy is reserved. Power (political) is retained. Power (mechanical, electrical, potential) is wasted.

Two smaller, personal and random but related events took place, just after the UK Government’s thumbs down for the Pentland Firth project, which helped further focus my mind on just what power (political) and power (mechanical) are and what they mean to us, the people who live and work in Scotland.

The first was that I met a friend of mine who is a retired engineer from Dounreay who has had a Damascene conversion to renewable energy. He, unprompted by me, lamented the short sightedness of the Tories in Westminster in relation to MayGen and their tidal array, but said it was down to their addiction to nuclear and the spiralling cost of new nuclear. Most significantly, he went on, the Hinkley Point C farrago, the cost of which in July had risen by £1.5bn to £19.6bn and the construction of which could be delayed by at least fifteen months.

The second thing was that the morning I met my friend I had just signed a contract with a publisher to have my “Selected Poems” published. Now this is a major thing for me but perhaps not for anyone else and I won’t bore you with the details other than to say it represents 25 years of work, and that’s a lot of energy.

All these things are related. My credo as a poet and a citizen is that poetry is energy and energy is freedom and freedom is poetry. This is, I admit, is an extension of the late Hamish Henderson’s cultural rallying cry of “Poetry becomes people”, which itself channelled both Heinrich Heine and Antonio Gramsci into vibrant life.

One of the qualities the ancient Greeks prized in lyric poetry, which they considered to be the greatest of all the arts, was energeia. This translates, more or less, as the actualization of a potential. The energy the Greeks prized was the energy need for living. For them, some 2,800 years ago, pleasure is an energeia of the human body and mind whereas happiness is more simply the energeia of a human being a human. I would argue that this generation of Tory politicians are actively supressing the potential for the Scots to achieve political “happiness”, by that I mean happiness to be the actualization of a potential, by serving the needs and interests of their own elite at the expense of the common good of the Scottish people. What else but an example of this elite interest was the refusal of the second stage funding for MayGen in the Pentland Firth?

According to the poet and critic Allen Grossman, “Poetry becomes a principle of power invoked by all of us against our vanishing.”

What is vanishing is the political threshing floor where ideas can be presented, discussed and acted upon. The perpetual chaos the Tories have deliberately strewn across this space, which is one of the tactics of their Brexit coup, has stymied political opposition, especially in Scotland: it denies alternative narratives a purchase. Waiting for the un-chaos of a post-Brexit world is a dangerous ploy for the Independence movement, most especially in setting the time for a second referendum. The Tories will spread chaos indefinitely. It is what they do. They disguise it as “bumbling on” as “Good old Blighty” and all that gut-turning, brain frying, Bo-Bo Borising rot that undermines democratic engagement and social and economic progress, not to mention cultural participation. What is vanishing, day by day, is democracy itself.

The sooner we understand the real Tory tactics, and not the official, BBC sanctioned dog-dance in which Theresa May and David Davis appear nightly (bemused, sleekit, vain) spouting well-rehearsed lies about the myth of “progress” and “decisive steps forward in Brexit talks”, and all the rest of it, the sooner we in Scotland can create alternative scenarios. We cannot afford to “wait and see”, which is more or less what the SNP are proposing. In as much as there is no forward movement in what the Tories are up to, which is confusing, divisive, self-interested, backward looking, the lack of ambition form the SNP also has no energeia. What it is, is inertia. That is a form of anti-energy we literally cannot afford.

The Tories have no energeia because they have no forward movement, they are not part of the future, they insist upon a permanent “now”. Their right wing nostalgia consigns Scotland to a permanent past. The vast Highland shooting estates are signifiers of this condition.

Scotland is a poetic nation with a constructive and optimistic population which is why I think it has, over the years, produced such an abundance of fine poets and engineers. James Clerk Maxwell, a great poetry lover, managed to calculate the composition of the rings of Saturn by observing the natural world. He turned what he saw in nature into mathematical symbols and confounded the Victorian world with the accuracy of his calculations. Poetry too is observation. Poets, like the physicist Clerk Maxwell, observe the natural world and the symbols we use to reveal its meaning are words. The revelation is what science and literature have in common. It was Einstein who noted that “Pure mathematics is, in its way, the poetry of logical ideas.”

Independence for Scotland is a logical idea, so we must be alive to the present by being as aware as we can be to what is possible. The island in the middle of the Pentland Firth is called Stroma. It is in the channel to the south of Stroma where MayGen have their tidal stream turbines. Stroma, in old Norse Straumr-øy, means “the island in the stream”; the “stream” being the second fastest tidal current in the world, which reaches up to 11 mph. This is the poetry of the North Sea meeting the Atlantic and its energeia is provided by the pull of the Moon. Here, physically, the anti-social chaos of the Tories, created by their Brexit coup, is literally countered by the measurability of nature, and the energy potential of the Pentland Firth which is an example of “the poetry of logical ideas.”

The joy of it is that it is there, it has always been there since the world was born, and will always be there as long as humanity has need of electricity. Poetry is energy and energy is freedom and freedom is poetry. We do not need to “wait and see” in order to become a sustainable economy or an independent nation: the means to that end I see every day in the sea. We do not need to be brainwashed by the media who, as the Greek poet George Seferis put it, have “Sleepwrapped you in green leaves like a tree.” Our observation must become our revelation, our political awakening, the release of our collective energeia, the positive action of a confidant people.

To return to Hamish Henderson again, because what he says about creativity in this interview given in 1966, is relevant to this debate.

“What Wilde wrote in De Profundis has some bearing on this… when he says that the object of love is to love. To feel itself in the joy of its own being. To a certain extent this is poetry too, one shouldn’t divide it between the moment of creation and the created completed thing. It’s the joy of itself to feel itself in being…to have this sensation of the thing moving and being and in existence, and not dead and failing… this has always with me taken the shape of direct communication, not so much communication via the printed page, although I have published things here and there. I have preferred to read poetry out, and if it is a song, to sing it.”

So, with our country, our engineering, our poetry, we have to allow it to “feel itself in being…” If we do we will not vanish, much as the Tories would love us to do and actually treat us as if we have.

If the SNP Government is serious about a Scottish National Investment Bank then MayGen’s tidal array in the Pentland Firth must be a first priority. When Scotland produces all her own energy and is independent of imported power and electricity then Scotland will become politically an independent country. We have “to sing it”. Let it be the Tories who do the vanishing.

©George Gunn 2017.

George Gunn’s novel “The Great Edge” is available from Grace Notes ISBN: 978-1-907676-94-9


We really need your support to develop and we’d like to ask you to support us by donating to us here.

We’ve got big plans to launch our new site, to launch new publishing and events projects, and to extend our platform of writers – but all of this needs your support.

Bella Caledonia remains free (and ad-free) and takes me hundreds of hours a month to research, write, commission and edit. If you value what I do, please consider supporting with a recurring monthly donation of your choosing. GoCardless to set up a small monthly donation to support independent journalism in Scotland.


Comments (7)

Join the Discussion

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  1. bringiton says:

    It is clear why the incompetent Tories in Westminster want to stifle Scottish renewables.
    They are committed to a vastly expensive nuclear programme and they do not want that shown up for the white elephant it really is.
    Secondly,they do not want England to be seen as being dependent on Scotland for energy supply,or anything else for that matter.
    If this doesn’t demonstrate the need for a Scottish investment bank then I don’t know what does.
    As long as we continue to be dependent on anything from London,we are always going to be held back and they are doing it deliberately.

  2. Wul says:

    Excellent piece and full of profound truth.

    The perma-chaos of the Tories strongly reminds me of the situation I, and many others, found ourselves in when working for local government and the NHS; a constant churn of manager-driven “re-organisation”. Endless opportunities for the managerial class to make a name for themselves and justify their existence. Their main purpose becoming the “delivery” of endless budget cuts instead of the running of an effective public service.

    The front-line staff (who worked with the very people who payed our wages) were left bewildered, demoralised and fearful for their jobs. The culture of caring and public service wiped out by the endless & time consuming “tick box” culture of gradually starved services.

    The result is that the good people leave, often ill and broken, or sometimes die.

    It doesn’t need to be like this. If we realise that we are worthy of better and that we posses the energy and resources to make Scotland a better place we can actually do it.

    George is right. This current chaos isn’t an accident, its a fully realised strategy for emptying our pockets and making us slaves.

  3. Wul says:

    How much energy must be available from millions of tons of seawater moving at 11mph? A very-big-number would be my guess.

    How reliable are the movements of moon and tide? Pretty reliable I’d say.

    And yet here we are, being asked to dig deep into our pockets to pay for a highly unstable, deadly, toxic, expensive means of energy production built & controlled by foreign powers and commissioned by a government that has shown utter contempt for Scotland’s people.

    We must be fu***ng mad to be putting up with this folks.

  4. w.b.robertson says:

    Must have been 30 years ago, or even longer, when a guy called Salter at Edinburgh University was leading the world with research into sea energy schemes. Scotland was sitting with tidal power on its doorstep. What an opportunity. What an indictment on the politicians of all parties for the stagnation since.

  5. Alf Baird says:

    I’m still waiting on the SNP majority of MPs setting up shadow ministries for all so-called ‘reserved powers’, based in Scotland of course, which I suggested when they were 56. What are they afraid of, the Guardia Civil?

  6. Paul Carline says:

    An excellent article. Just one – perhaps seemingly minor – quibble: there was no “serious Tube bomb attack”. That was merely what we were told by the complicit media. Photos show merely a small fire in a bucket inside a Lidl bag – no bomb. (Cf, for example: https://rehmat1.com/2017/09/16/london-tube-bucket-bomb-another-terror-hoax/).

    This is entirely relevant to George Gunn’s article because it is one of the primary means by which modern centralised, right-wing, governments control their populations, keeping them in fear of an imaginary enemy, whilst using the hoaxes to increase the strength and fear-inducing potential of the so-called ‘security services’.

    The reaction of the Spanish state to the Catalan independence referendum may have been extreme for Europe, but it is by no means unimaginable for the UK.

  7. George Gunn says:

    Yes, Paul, I take your point. Up here in Caithness we live with a security regime at Dounreay on constant high alert and in a constant state of boredom with nothing to do but construct demons lurking in the boots of people’s cars coming in from Tesco, the Co-op or Lidl’s in Thurso – all those possible insurgents on their way back to the croft.

Help keep our journalism independent

We don’t take any advertising, we don’t hide behind a pay wall and we don’t keep harassing you for crowd-funding. We’re entirely dependent on our readers to support us.

Subscribe to regular bella in your inbox

Don’t miss a single article. Enter your email address on our subscribe page by clicking the button below. It is completely free and you can easily unsubscribe at any time.