2007 - 2021

Intelligence Finance


Sir Fitzroy Hew Royle Maclean, 1st Baronet, KT, CBE (11 March 1911 – 15 June 1996) Scottish soldier, writer and politician

What’s emerging is not an alternative case for the Union but a war against the limited democracy we have. The revelation that Better Together is bankrolled (‘Tory to the core‘) by spivs, spooks and spies is maybe not surprising but it does clarify matters. All the big donors were Conservative supporters. But there’s murky backers emerging all over the place. Chief amongst them are the company ‘Hakluyt’ (named after a 16th century author who wrote about journeys to far-off lands). According to former Director Christopher James, Hakluyt: “places an unparalleled private intelligence network at the personal disposal of senior commercial figures.”

The firm was accused in a 2001 Sunday Times article of helping BP Plc and Royal Dutch Shell Plc spy on Greenpeace using a German agent called Manfred Schlickenrieder, who posed as a film-maker. A 1997 message in German from then Hakluyt Director Mike Reynolds discussed the location of Greenpeace ships and asked Schlickenrieder to use his informants to find out how the organization would respond to being sued.

Sir Keith Craig an ‘army veteran’ who works for Hakluyt gave £10,000. The Sunday Herald reports:

… perhaps the most intriguing donor – is Christopher Wilkins, the chairman of North British Wind Energy Ltd, who gave £10,000.

A former Welsh Guards officer, in 1995 he helped found the Mayfair-based private intelligence company Hakluyt alongside several former members of the secret intelligence service MI6. Hakluyt, which continues to employ ex-spies, was later found to have infiltrated and spied on Greenpeace on behalf of Shell and BP.

Wilkins, 72, last night said he had set up Hakluyt, but had left 15 years ago. “I am not in that game. I was on the edge of that game. I did Hakluyt. I helped set it up. It was an interesting operation at an interesting time and life has moved on.”

He’s not alone amongst people with a background in ‘intelligence’ and ‘ex-military’. Simon Crane, CEO of the security company Edinburgh International (founded in Baghdad in 2003), which ‘supplies bodyguards’ in Afghanistan, gave £15,000.  According to their website, Edinburgh International are now a ‘full service’ security company who provide a one-stop-shop of outsourced services to organisations operating in ‘challenging environments’. Their permanent locations are UK, US, UAE, Iraq, Afghanistan, Sudan, Lebanon, Turkey, Nepal, Australia and Jordan. See their site here.

After Vitol, it’s these guys.

But whilst it’s amusing to think how this funding platform places Scottish Labour – essentially as Tory shills for the Union – the idea that these spooks are all Conservative contacts is not quite right.

Hakluyt & Co (now Hakluyt Ltd) was founded by Fitzroy MacLean in 1995. He was close friends with Elizabeth Smith, the wife of the late Labour leader who was on the Hakluyt board between 1998 and 2002. Smith himself was a Steering Commitee Member of the Bilderberg Group – as disclosed by Robin Ramsay in The Rise of New Labour.

What are we to make of this backing?

Derek Bateman puts it well (‘Know who your friends are’):

I was one of those who prickled at suggestions after the Radical Scotland conference claim that the No’s were the rich Yes were the poor. On this evidence I’m wrong. No is funded by the wealthy, the greedy, the seedy and the undemocratic. I loved the statement from Donald Houston who more or less own Ardnamurchan, an iconic peninsula in our country’s history. It’s the location of Castle Tioram, symbol of windswept resistance, which was burned down deliberately by the Macdonalds in 1715 to prevent it falling again into British Hanovarian hands. Sadly Donald is made of softer stuff. “We have spent 300 years building up a Union between our countries that has achieved so much”, he says. You can almost hear his incomprehension.  It certainly has achieved much for him since he can afford to give £100,000 and half a million via his companies. The killer line though is: “I hope that other people in the same position as myself are also willing to contribute whatever they can.”

This is really about interest groups and individuals clinging on to raw power.  The hilarious suggestion by the Bold Baron Wallace of Tankerness, that he’d stick around in the House of Lords after an independence vote is just more evidence that the penny hasn’t quite dropped for these people (‘Peers could remain Lords’).

It’s not just that the forces of the secret state back the No lobby – from Diomhair to the recent example of Amendment 54  there’s an urgency for power to be retained and there’s little qualms about how to do it.

The pronouncements of Andy Burnham on a pan-UK health policy make it clear the trajectory for unification if No wins. But what we know today is that the forces of the British State are emerging to back Project Fear.

But what don’t we know that they’re up to? Let’s find out.

Comments (5)

Join the Discussion

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  1. andygm1 says:

    Anyone who has read Eastern Approaches by Fitzroy McLean can be in no doubt that, if he wasn’t actually working directly for the security services, he was very closely associated with them throughout most of his career, both as a diplomat and a soldier. He was also a Tory MP, so it’s virtually the full set.

  2. Ken MacColl says:

    Relevant quote from Donald Houston in today’s Herald,
    “The people of the Highlands that I speak with consider the SNP government in Edinburgh to be completely remote from our opinions and our way of life.”

    This is doubtless true and we should all be truly thankful for that !
    If only he could meet some Highlanders.

  3. George Gunn says:

    The Laird o Ardnamurchan would have to go to Canada to do that

  4. Mike Gunn says:

    This article starts digging at one big reason there is such opposition from the Conservatives to independence, despite the fact that electorally it would greatly help them.
    Land. Ownership. Grab.

    The Laird o Ardnamurchan is a prime example. The underwriting and unsaid fear from the the ‘No’ camp is the possible end of feudal ownership of the Victorian playground that is Scotland.

    It’s astonishing to me that Labour hasn’t seen this agenda and fear. They have the chance to re-invent themselves and stand for what historically Labour has represented but instead they are being led by the nose by Tory funders and land owners to the precipice of their meaningful existence.

    Labour needs to wake up from its coma.

Help keep our journalism independent

We don’t take any advertising, we don’t hide behind a pay wall and we don’t keep harassing you for crowd-funding. We’re entirely dependent on our readers to support us.

Subscribe to regular bella in your inbox

Don’t miss a single article. Enter your email address on our subscribe page by clicking the button below. It is completely free and you can easily unsubscribe at any time.