2007 - 2021

We don’t need the Hate Van Here


Bella is kicking off it’s own campaign: ‘We don’t need the Hate Van here’. We believe this is a disgraceful attempt to intimidate people of colour and feeds an already febrile attitude of race-conflict in England, actively being nurtured by the EDL, UKIP and the Tory party. 

SNP MP Pete Wishart said the vans, which have so far appeared only in London, would force illegal immigrants “underground and intimidate peaceful and legitimate communities”.

“These billboards are clearly designed to address the growing influence of UKIP and the anti-immigration plank of their agenda. It seems the UK government is acting in desperation, pandering to a swing to the right in some places south of the Border, and using inflammatory rhetoric in a bid to respond to UKIPs rise in the polls.” The SNP MP has written to the Home Secretary asking if there are any plans for these posters to come to Scotland.

In response to the UK government’s racist van antics we’ll be exploring alternatives to the now far-right coalition with Brit parties jumping over each other to outdo themselves by reiterating the language of the BNP in the 1970s. We are asking progressive parties in Scotland to articulate their position in the light of the referendum.

By Alex Randall. This post first appeared on the website of the UK migration and climate change coalition.

The Green Party in the UK recently came out in support of more open and humane immigration policy. Their stance aims to challenge the growing anti-migrant policies and rhetoric of the other main political parties. However the Green Party’s new position has been attacked by some of their own members, who argue that many party members are concerned that “a high level of net immigration” into the UK makes protecting the environment harder.

There are good reasons that green parties (in any country) should support open and humane immigration policies, beyond the need to challenge the anti migrant rhetoric of the other parties. Green parties and organisations must recognies that migration is one the most powerful tools we have for coping with climate change. This is a clear challenge to the greens who support tighter controls on immigration.

1. Migration can increases resilience to the impacts of climate change. Millions of people – mostly in developing countries – have their livelihoods destroyed every year by climate -linked disasters like floods and hurricanes. Many of these areas also have extensive out migration. When a disaster hits, this existing out migration has some positive consequences. When people migrate out of these areas they usually move in order to find work. Most migrants send money home to their families. This flow of money called remittances has become a fairly large part of many economies. It makes up about 10% of the Philippines’ GDP, for example. When a disaster does strike a family with migrant workers abroad will continue to receive a steady flow of remittances, when their own local livelihoods have been destroyed (at least temporarily) by the disaster. Having household members working abroad has become a very important way for some places to increase their ability to survive the immediate aftermath of climate linked disasters. In many places remittances have become informal disaster relief funds. Developed countries have a responsibility to allow this kind of movement. Green parties and organisations should support developed country governments in allowing this kind of movement as it clearly helps vulnerable developing countries cope with climate change impacts.

migration and the changing climate in the Arctic (from the Climate and Migration Project)

2. Many people are moving to find work as their livelihoods are degraded by the impacts of climate change. For many people this is the only available way of adapting to climate change. Patterns of seasonal and circular movement are increasingly becoming ways for people to maintain household income as climate change adversely affects their livelihood. For example, farmers – especially in dry-land areas – may move temporarily to find non-farm work during periods of drought. Farmers may also move to other farming areas that are less affected by adverse conditions like water stress, then return if and when conditions improve. Most of this movement is short distance and internal. However, more open immigration policies would allow this movement to become increasingly international if people needed to move further in order to find alternative work.

3. Remittances can also become an important form of climate change adaptation funding. Money sent home by migrants to their families is increasingly being invested in projects and activities that help those families adapt to climate change. This doesn’t mean the money is invested in the kind of mega-projects that we might think of as climate adaptation like building sea defenses. Rather the money is often invested adapting farming practices so that communities can continue farming in hotter or drier conditions. For example remittances have been invested in crop switching, the process of moving from growing one crop to another in response to changing environmental conditions. This usually requires some upfront capital. There are situations where finding this has been made possible the inflow of remittances. Remittances are also increasingly being used for investment in small scale water storage to increase a farming community’s ability to cope with water stress.

Political parties that are worried about the impacts of climate change on the most vulnerable people must recognise that many people are using migration as a way of surviving climate change. Their stance on immigration must reflect this.

Alex Randall works for the Climate Outreach and Information Network running their climate migration project.
– See more at: http://brightgreenscotland.org/index.php/2013/07/immigration-a-vital-part-of-the-solution-to-climate-change/#sthash.6tRLNsje.dpuf

Comments (6)

Join the Discussion

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  1. Albalha says:

    And of course there’s the Border Agency turning up now at tube stations, this just posted on the New Statesman

  2. Abulhaq says:

    As far as Scotland is concerned immigration is a positive. We are relatively underpopulated and ageing. Immigrants tend to be motivated, educated and young. Given the turbulence in the MidEast I would hope our government would open wide the doors to those seeking a new life in a peaceful, stable and, I trust, welcoming environment. Obviously, without independence, we are stuck in the unfriendly cycle of UK ie English politics.

    1. Well I hope, following a winning ‘YES’ vote, that my Australian born children will be granted a Scottish passport, and can access a free university placement if they so choose….because at present, if we show up to a border (Scottish or English) we get questioned as to why we are there, how we can fund ourselves, and stamped a maximum of a 6 month stay. Pretty sad when ALL my family (maternal and paternal) are born and bred Scots going right back to the Picts…when someone else who has no ties to Scotland gets a free pass…Im not a racist, but pick and choose carefully…

  3. Dave Coull says:

    No way. If the hate van should ever show signs of travelling to Scotland its movement should be physically prevented.

  4. Charles Patrick O'Brien says:

    Scotland does not have the old-age time-bomb as we die younger that the south east,a lot of Scots don’t live long enough to collect any pension,but be that as it may we would still like to have some nice new friends,who want to be Scottish.

  5. Tocasaid says:

    While not wishing to encourage illegal direct action like Dangerous Dave above…. I can sympathise with his sentiments and certainly wouldn’t shed any tears should some misfortune befall the Hate Van.

    Or, for balance, let’s see something similar to advertise the names and faces of fraudulent MPs and those who claim sky-high expenses? Or for tax-dodging corporations and millionaires?

Help keep our journalism independent

We don’t take any advertising, we don’t hide behind a pay wall and we don’t keep harassing you for crowd-funding. We’re entirely dependent on our readers to support us.

Subscribe to regular bella in your inbox

Don’t miss a single article. Enter your email address on our subscribe page by clicking the button below. It is completely free and you can easily unsubscribe at any time.