Arts & Culture - Review - Anti-Capitalism

2007 - 2021

Evidence, Risk and the Wicked Questions

Around 200 people crammed into the Martin Hall at New College on the Mound in Edinburgh last night to attend the launch of Arguing for Independence: Evidence, Risk and the Wicked Issues, the book my father, Stephen Maxwell, finished writing shortly before he died in April, at the age 69. I was one of four speakers on a panel which included Jim Eadie, SNP MSP for Edinburgh Southern, journalist Joyce McMillan and First Minister Alex Salmond. The launch was chaired by the inestimable Owen Dudley Edwards.

Each of the contributions reflected on the role my dad played in Scottish public life over the course of forty years, both as a leading intellectual force on the nationalist left and an important figure in the Scottish voluntary sector. Joyce McMillan suggested his life invited us to “continue asking questions” about the nature of our political culture and how it could be improved, while Jim Eadie spoke of his “legendary SNP conference speeches in the ‘70s and ‘80s, effortlessly combining intellect and rhetoric”.

In an address notable for its personal candour, the First Minister said my dad’s “presence in the national movement was itself an argument for independence” and that it was difficult “to imagine an SNP without Stephen Maxwell, a Scotland without Stephen Maxwell”. Owen, with his usual thunderous eloquence, stressed the conviction which underpinned my father’s lifelong engagement in politics: opposition to nuclear weapons, in particular to the stationing of the British nuclear fleet at Faslane.

In my introduction, I talked about how Arguing for Independence reminds us that the Scottish ‘constitutional’ debate is not, at its core, about the constitution. It’s about the distribution of economic and political power in Britain, Scotland’s social and cultural futures and the role Scotland should play in international affairs. I also expressed regret at the timing of my father’s death, coming just at the start of a referendum campaign he spent so much of his life preparing for and to which he would have made an enormous contribution.

All in all, the event was an appropriate and moving tribute – an opportunity for those of us who knew my dad to remember his humility, his generosity and his intelligence. I can’t help but think that he would have been embarrassed by the scale of the thing, though. No doubt he would have settled for 25 people in the Quaker Meeting House, with no press, no praise and minimal applause. But last night was nothing less than he – and his crucial new book – deserve.

Arguing for Independence is available to order now from Word Power Books.

Comments (0)

Join the Discussion

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  1. burdzeyeview says:

    Lovely and fitting tribute, and just sad I missed the event. But there’s still his book and I look forward to hearing Stephen’s unique voice ringing true as I read it. A great way to mark your dad’s long contribution to the body politic, James, by publishing it. It will prove to be one of the seminal works I’m sure as we journey onto independence. Away to order a copy now…

  2. Andrew says:

    The Amazon link is missing its colon

    1. bellacaledonia says:

      Now it’s fixed ; )

  3. Ordered, but I would have preferred the Kindle edition for traveling.

  4. Roseanna Cunningham says:

    It was a great tribute to Stephen & his book will now be required reading!

  5. Ken MacColl says:

    Good to learn of this publication that I look forward ro purchasing. I well remember Stephen’s compelling contributions to SNP gatherings on the 70s and 80s as the National movement gathered strength. I was aware of his more recent role with SCVO.
    I last met him at a sparsely attended CND rally in Glasgow a couple of years ago where we shared reminiscences walking out to Kelvingrove.

Help keep our journalism independent

We don’t take any advertising, we don’t hide behind a pay wall and we don’t keep harassing you for crowd-funding. We’re entirely dependent on our readers to support us.

Subscribe to regular bella in your inbox

Don’t miss a single article. Enter your email address on our subscribe page by clicking the button below. It is completely free and you can easily unsubscribe at any time.