Politics - Scotland

2007 - 2022

Japan, England and the Social Aspiration Gap

Imagine a country riven by a culture of deference and conservatism, wholly dependent on nuclear power and desperately short of a drive for social aspiration for change. I speak of course of England, a country sadly lacking in Matthew Taylor’s tasteless blog post in which he decided to compare Scotland and Japan, a country facing unprecedented humanitarian crisis, and found Scotland worse off. Our collective crime? He chides us that we haven’t embraced New Labour modernisation and remain, stubbornly too left wing.

Amazingly Taylor wrote this en route to speak in Scotland and then went in a tremendous huff when it was pointed out to him that this was a) gibberish and b) insulting gibberish, tweeting “I don’t intend to offend but I see English opinions are unwelcome North Of The Border – lesson learnt – good bye.” Yes Matthew the problem here is our foolish sensitivity not that fact you have just compared Scotland to a country suffering from tsunami, nuclear meltdown and earthquake devastation.

So what does he say?   His arguments are threefold, first we suffer from a terrible lack of choice, second we have a hopeless lack of ‘social aspiration’ and third we lack a ‘strong right wing  voice’ or ‘modernising’ element in our political firmament because of our ‘antipathy to New Labour’.

As Gerry Hassan wrote in Open Democracy: “We know that there is a tradition of criticising Scotland from afar or in the briefest of visits north bringing your prejudices with you unchallenged. This used to be the terrain of the centre-right, of Thatcherites such as Nigel Lawson in the 1980s and The Spectator, but now what remains of the British centre-left has begun to join in.”

You can’t imagine a figure in a similar position doing the same whilst traveling south the speak in London. Can you?

The lack of pluralism in Scottish politics is something of a nonsense, if you think of the history of the parliament when we had six Greens, four SSP and a healthy handful of independents. Our proportional system makes this more likely than at Westminster, its a point which seems to have been lost on poor Matthew.

If there is an affinity between Scottish parties this is mostly a reflection of a nation with a more coherent set of political values, and a state that has in recent times been more skewed by Labour attempting to cherry-pick SNP policies in a bizarre frenzy of policy-theft (tuition fees, council tax freeze, defending accident and emergency, help for first time-buyers) the list goes on. As Iain Macwirter puts it “You sometimes wonder if Labour has any idea of its own”. Indeed you do. The irony of all of this is of course one of the reasons why Labour is so devoid of fresh thinking is that, after the Blair era (in which Taylor played a prominent part) they are rudderless, virtually leaderless and increasingly clueless. After Tony’s Cronies, the expenses scandal, the Devine Comedy, and Purcell’s clanjamfry, Scottish Labour have nothing to say.

And Taylor speaks of ‘social aspiration’? Taylor writes: “The idea that Japan could turn this crisis into a national conversation about a new idea of citizenship and society is inspiring…which brings me mournfully to Scotland.”

National Conversation? Exploring a new idea of citizenship? That has a certain ring to it. No doubt if Taylor had any working knowledge of Scottish politics he wouldn’t have used this phrase, as he’d have known that such a project was under way before being undermined by Labour drone politicians committed to Calman.

But the idea of a lack of social aspiration is probably more insulting that his deep-level ignorance.

We are about to enter a fresh hell of state sponsored Royalism with the latest junket seeming to prove the old Marx quote of ‘history repeating itself, first as tragedy, second as farce.’ As England prepares its street parties for Kate and William in an age of austerity it’s bizarre to argue that a lack of social aspiration pervades Scotland. If anything Scottish civil society is straining to counter the Tory / Quis Dem cuts delivered after the economic debacle of Taylor’s New Labour and desperate to transcend the ‘Union Dividend’ that leaves 1 in 10 of our children living  in what Save the Children term the most “severe poverty”. Earlier this month the charity said they feared that number would rise “dramatically” due to Scots having the lowest chance of finding work in the UK.

The charity urged that ‘urgent action’ is needed in Scotland’s most deprived areas to prevent a “lost generation”. So there’s no shortage of ‘social aspiration’ there is a definite gap in the resources and mechanisms to induce the profound change needed to achieve it.

The final piece of Taylor’s odd political jigsaw puzzle is his the idea that what is really missing here is a strong right wing voice or even a modernising wing (nb ‘modernising is New Labour code for privatisation). We have – it’s true – refused to embrace  ‘a diversification of public sector delivery’. It’s called having a a different political culture, and a different set of traditions. This to the unreconstructed New Labour elite, like some Tsarist loyalists still proclaiming the Romanov dynasty, is intolerable. In their eyes, Gerri Halliwell is still sporting her Union Jack mini-dress, Des’ree was still being hummed by Cabinet Ministers and talk is of an ‘ethical foreign policy’. It’s difficult to understate the extent to which the very idea of ‘Britain’ ‘New Britain’ and ‘Britishness’ was at the heart of much of the Blair’s blethering.

Instead we stand on the verge of a renewables revolution that could transform Scottish energy output, structure and demand as we move towards a low carbon nation. That’s not just a social aspiration that’s a socio-ecological one. It’s one that has nothing to do with Labour’s tragic ideologically-driven commitment to new nuclear power that – like much of the New Labour project – looks to be spent. It’s the sort of technology and expertise that Scottish engineers might well be exporting to Japan and other countries as we attempt to help reconstruct that stricken land. That’s the sort of international solidarity that should be part of the vision for a new Scotland.

Comments (0)

Join the Discussion

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  1. Welsh Sion says:

    I thought you might like to enjoy the Freudian slip that appeared when this excellent comment entered my e-mail inbox. I quote:

    “I speak of course of England, a country sadly lacking in Matthew Taylor’s tasteless bog [sic.] post…”


  2. Ray Bell says:

    I don’t think it is a valid comparison… but…

    * Japan has a problem with single party politics (“Liberal Democrats” no less), with the same party in power for decades.
    * Japan has a problem with recognising Ainu heritage and just how wide its influence has been on Japanese culture, including Shinto (kami is an Ainu word, to be found in both kamikaze and O-Kami, the Emperor’s title), placenames (the old name of Tokyo was Ezo, which is thought by some to be Ainu in origin)
    * Japan is a surprisingly large country, but its population is crammed into a few narrow strips.

    But in the current situation it is not generally a appropriate comparison.

    p.s. Sion, “bog” indeed. LOL!

  3. Jock Mad McMad says:

    Tory Energy Minister: Scotland must be happy to share her oil and gas wealth with the rest of the UK….

    Tory Birkie Laird: Calman is the midwife of Scottish Independence…

    Tory Chancellor: I’m going to take £10 billion out of the Scottish purse over the next five tears to cover the ass of my City of London pals and you can’t do a thing to stop me.

    New Labour London spokesperson: The Scottish people are the problem with Scotland because they are unreconstructed socialists with a small s …..

    Liberaldem Scottish Secretary: We know best, just do as we tell you and go back to your black houses and await the next clearances

    Scottish Labour Leader …………. sorry no one knows who he or she is.

    Scottish Liberty:

    Where are those Scots whose lives, thought cheap, bought dear?
    Who Percy’s knights fell foul at Clatteringshaw
    That Edward’s Bohun sneered at as cattle before being gored by the bull.
    Where are those Scots who dared believe we are a nation state;
    A people’s realm and sovereign for all time?

    Where are those Scots whose principles, philosophy and fore sight
    Unseated Crowns, raised liberty’s song, revolutionised and freed nations?
    Yet home were craven, cowed; slithering to suck the hind teat
    Of Westminster’s Empire building whore,
    Selling Scotland cheap, for their own back pocket.

    Where are those Scots whose spirit cries foul at Westminster’s false chimera?
    No longer victims waiting idly by to be mugged of oil and other wealth
    By London’s City; impoverished by neo-liberal whim, affectation and ignorance.
    Whose rage at Labour’s pass, raise fire and brimstone worthy of Maclean or Maxton,
    Seeking socialism of care and people – not greed, patronage and self interest.

    I fear they are gone, leaving liberty to the empty hills, ghost clachans, wind swept crags –
    Of “Granny’s Heilan’ Hame”, short bread tins, kilts and Walter Scott’s romantic pap:
    Lost in their skinny lattes and thinner thoughts of ermine, gong’s or knighthoods
    Still snivelling Westminster’s tune – too wee, too poor, too stupid – we’re lucky
    London still wants us; so touch your Jockanese forelocks southerly and be happy.

    Scotland’s declaration to the world can not find one, let lone one hundred, to hold
    And cry so long and loud, the call held dear for seven hundred years of Scotland’s liberties;
    “But for freedom – for that alone, which no honest man gives up but with life itself.”
    No honest man – Aye, there’s the rub and irony too – the truth hit home from 1320.
    So Calman’s poison wins where Longshanks’ army failed an’ we’re aw deid.

  4. David MacGille-Mhuire says:

    Taylor-“San” or pseudo-sahib (imperialistically interchangeable): A flash scut with the thinnest veneer of faux internationalist insights.

    The Chinese even pre-Mao, witness the Boxer Rebellion, had more than adequate solutions for this type of carpetbagging comprador.

    The Japanese of the pre-Meiji Restoration Shogunate also had their methods for dealing with such parasitic adventurers and none too pretty to say the least.

    I trust he will remain in the huff and not reprise

  5. Byrnsweord says:

    Fascinating blog. As an Englishman who has detailed the profound and crippling wealth gap in and across his country, I feel I need to learn a good deal more about Scotland.

Help keep our journalism independent

We don’t take any advertising, we don’t hide behind a pay wall and we don’t keep harassing you for crowd-funding. We’re entirely dependent on our readers to support us.

Subscribe to regular bella in your inbox

Don’t miss a single article. Enter your email address on our subscribe page by clicking the button below. It is completely free and you can easily unsubscribe at any time.