2007 - 2022

Scotland Speaks

Tonight’s leaders debates (sic) is the latest line in efforts to distort the electoral process reducing the imagined choice at the UK General Election. ITV1 will broadcast the show from 8.30 pm in Manchester. Sky and BBC One will host debates on successive Thursdays.

Bella Caledonia and others are combining to create a Twitter protest against this attack on democracy by big media.  To take part just Twitter your protest using #leadersdebates and #scotlandspeaks.

1. This is a deliberately false representation of the options available to people in Scotland and Wales. This is a media manipulation presented as ‘putting the politicians on the spot’ but which has actually been the result of months of careful negotiations from Tory & Labour spin-doctors.

2. This is a narrowing of the political choices to just three white men with virtually identical policies.

3. This excludes the leaders of Scotland and Wales, the vision of the Greens and others.

4. An English based UK debate critically confuses issues about what matters are devolved and what are retained at a Westminster level.  The ‘domestic issues’ which will be debated tonight – things like health, education and policing – are all controlled in Scotland by Holyrood.

5. This flawed and biased format must not be allowed to become the accepted norm for distorting political coverage.

6. This institutionalised media bias is a continutation of the failing Westminister democracy; corrupt, unaccountable, and lacking in transparency.

7. Alex Salmond was the only LEADER of a major political party NOT to be investigated under the expenses scandal.

8.This part of a wider media affect of trivialising and narrowing democracy to a celebrity politics of presidential image-making. Views that are outwith the Unionist model or beyond a certain cultural norm are treated with contempt. There are examples elsewhere (ie Canada) where a more complicated political structure can get better representation.

9. Each debate will have a different protest. Go to: http://www.bbc.co.uk/complaints/homepage/ to complain directly to the BBC. Why should we be forced to pay for a service that excludes us?

10. To protest we suggest writing in English, Gaelic and Welsh or other minoritised or minority languages on Twitter using #tvdebates and #scotlandspeaks.

No TV without representation.

For more coverage on these issue see: Media Democracy –  Lesley Riddoch here – and for those issues you WON’T be hearing about tonight, Joan McAlpine here.

You can see the SNP’s rebuttal against this discrimation at these times:

BBC Scotland at 6.55 pm

STV at 6.25 pm

Channel 4 at 7.55 pm

Comments (16)

Join the Discussion

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  1. Lets see a #walesspeaks hashtag too

  2. bellacaledonia says:

    Good idea, thanks Darren.

  3. commenter says:

    “This is a narrowing of the political choices to just three white men with virtually identical policies.”

    Just one point. This racist (but no doubt intended to be anti-racist) comment doesn’t even make sense when you consider that Alex Salmond is white.

    Or maybe you’re saying they should have an orangey-brown man on too (Tommy Sheridan)?

  4. Robert Ross says:

    Is é an t-am ar son neamhspleáchas na hAlban anois! Agus caithfidh an Béarla ag iarraidh stop a chur leis an díospóireacht a rialú. iad féin is ní Theastaigh.

  5. bellacaledonia says:

    Watch the First Ministers attempt to explain why Scotland is excluded from the debate: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=p0kzXFHKagk

  6. Hythlodaeus says:

    I think that went rather well.

    I’m looking forward to seeing the analysis in the Scottish blogs tomorrow.

  7. bellacaledonia says:

    It was great, thanks to everyone for taking part. Lots of people began to get their heads around how Twitter works for the first time.

    We were mentioned as the best # tags (#scotlandspeaks and #walesspeaks) by C4 and appeared prominently throughout on the ITV live stream.

    I’m trying to get some figures but hundreds and hundreds of people picked up the #scotlandspeaks tag and used it and thousands saw our commentary. People were commenting in Gaelic and Welsh and protesting this manipulation of the electoral process. One tweet called it ‘Ballot rigging by broadcast’.

    1. It went really well.

      We picked up the campaign pretty early on, and spread the word, which it seems alot of people did.

  8. Pingback: #scotlandspeaks «
  9. Vronsky says:

    I’m new to Twitter. I’ve searched the online help but can find no mention of ‘hash tags’ or how to use them. Help!

    1. bellacaledonia says:

      Don’t worry, loads of people are new to Twitter.

      This is a hash tag: #

      You write your comment, and a link if you want, then afterwards just add #scotlandspeaks. That means everyone who’s using thta can follow the same conversation. If you use tiny url (http://tiny.cc/) you can shorten the links.

      Twitter then adds up all the ‘tweets’ using that hash tag – ‘#scotlandspeaks’ – and lists the most popular ones by country and topic so you can see who’s talking about what around the world.

  10. Vronsky says:

    So there’s no conversation that I can see – I just label my tweets and a machine somewhere adds them up?

Help keep our journalism independent

We don’t take any advertising, we don’t hide behind a pay wall and we don’t keep harassing you for crowd-funding. We’re entirely dependent on our readers to support us.

Subscribe to regular bella in your inbox

Don’t miss a single article. Enter your email address on our subscribe page by clicking the button below. It is completely free and you can easily unsubscribe at any time.